Analysis of Russell T. Davies' Commentary on Doctor Who

Key Points

• Russell T. Davies' Stance: He stated that "Doctor Who won't define his legacy." The speaker is skeptical about this claim, suggesting Doctor Who will indeed be a significant part of his legacy due to the controversy surrounding his tenure.

• Criticism of Doctor Who: The speaker critiques Davies' tenure with the show, implying that it was mishandled and poorly received, describing it as a "joke" and lamenting the direction the series took under his leadership.

• Other Works by Davies: Davies suggests that his legacy will be more defined by other works focused on LGBTQ+ themes, like "Queer as Folk," "Cucumber," "It's a Sin," and "Tiptoe," rather than Doctor Who.

• Upcoming Project 'Tiptoe': The show is described as focusing on two gay men in Manchester amidst cultural tensions. It’s positioned as a strong work by Davies, aimed at addressing contemporary LGBTQ+ issues.

• Public Perception and Ratings: There is mention of Doctor Who's declining ratings and public dissatisfaction, pointing out criticism about the show's quality and direction post-reboot.

• Industry Dynamics: The commentary touches on industry trends where individuals sometimes maintain roles despite failures, with Davies perceived as "failing up."

• Conclusion and Legacy: The speaker concludes with a satirical take, asserting Doctor Who will ultimately be intertwined with Davies' legacy due to the perceived negative impact of his tenure on the show.