Analysis of Discussion on 'Fantastic 4 First Steps' Film Reception

Key Points:

• Initial Topic and Reaction:

  • Recent reactions have emerged regarding the film 'Fantastic 4 First Steps,' with numerous individuals (influencers, critics, etc.) expressing strong opinions that the film has underperformed.
  • John Rosher is a notable critic emphasizing the alleged lack of intelligence among moviegoers as a reason for the film's failure compared to 'Jurassic World Rebirth.'

• Critique of John Rosher:

  • The speaker refers to John Rosher derogatorily, indicating a previous interaction or video about him.
  • Rosher’s tweet suggests placing blame on the audience rather than studios or film creators for movies failing at the box office.

• Argument Analysis:

  • The speaker criticizes Rosher's logic, arguing it's illogical to blame audience intelligence for 'Fantastic 4' and 'Superman' underperforming relative to 'Jurassic World.'
  • The speaker claims all mentioned films are mediocre, and making comparisons is flawed and oversimplified.

• Distribution and Film Critique:

  • Criticism is directed towards Rosher for dismissing the success of 'Jurassic World' due to its lower critical scores compared to audience enjoyment and box office success.
  • The speaker highlights that higher attendance naturally diversifies audience reactions, which can impact general score perceptions.

• Response to Rosher’s Argument:

  • Commentators have challenged Rosher's view, asserting studio decisions are influenced by consumer preferences, which he dismissed.
  • Discussion touches on global market differences, exemplified by Asia's preference for dinosaur films boosting 'Jurassic World' performance.

• Broader Industry Observations:

  • The speaker references broader market fatigue for superhero films, suggesting past successes aren't a guarantee for future interest.
  • Contentions about the industry also involve debates on box office obsession impacting creativity, as seen in conversations with other opinion leaders like Hunter Balding.

• Final Observations:

  • The speaker concludes that current trends could inform a decline in superhero film popularity and questions the future direction of such genres based on current box office trends.

Conclusion:

The discussion critiques the simplistic blame placed on audiences for film failures and calls into question the critic's analysis. It emphasizes the importance of market and audience dynamics and how they influence studio decisions and film successes across genres.