Note details

Alien Earth FIRST REVIEWS - "Haunting, Gory & Disgusting"

BY d1wpf
August 22, 2025
Public
Private
4122 views

Alien Earth: Initial Reviews Summary

Introduction

  • The first reviews for "Alien Earth" are out, a week prior to its official release.
  • Reviews appear largely positive with an aggregate score of 89% on Rotten Tomatoes based on 38 reviews.

Critical Commentary

Positive Feedback

  • United Press praises the show for exploring original ideas while staying faithful to the "Alien" franchise.
  • Grace Randolph describes it as "stunning," akin to an eight-hour movie, and one of Hulu's best offerings.
  • IGN sees it as a slick and scary evolution fitting for the franchise.
  • TV Guide applauds its inventive nature with appropriately haunting alien designs.
  • Total Film questions if it's the best since Cameron's "Aliens," citing its ambitious and often violent narrative.

Mixed Critiques

  • Variety notes the show's potential for exploring character depth beyond its monsters.
  • Hollywood Reporter acknowledges a slow burn start but a rewarding end.
  • IndieWire mentions less focus on xenomorph action, pushing the show's story forward instead.

Critical Observations

  • Consequence highlights the fun in discovering the sci-fi horrors themselves.
  • Slash Film found it boring with strange pacing and overcooked editing.
  • IndieWire remarks on the xenomorph being downplayed by the season's end, despite its terror.

Key Highlights

  • Noah Holly's direction is noted for its unique and disorienting vision.
  • The show offers a mixture of intense horror and character-driven stories.
  • "Alien Earth" hints at future expansions with multiple ship narratives.

Conclusion

The reviews suggest "Alien Earth" has a promising start with potential for longevity if adequately supported by its fan base. The excitement around its storytelling, coupled with its dedication to evolving the "Alien" franchise, gives it a hopeful prospect despite some critiques on pacing and focus.